Most of us remember school as a place where the rules were handed down from the top, and our only job was to follow them. But what happens when you flip that script, and give students the authority to build, defend, and police their own culture?
At Alpha, we call this Town Hall: a weekly student-led meeting where kids vote on their own rules, elect their own officials, and set the standards for their own community. It’s a cornerstone of the Alpha experience and a main driver of our students’ ownership over their culture.
Today I’m sharing the behind-the-scenes blueprint. Not only will you hear about how Town Hall works at Alpha, you’ll get a how-to guide for implementing this level of student agency in your own classroom or at your own dinner table tonight.
Thanks for being here. If you enjoy reading/listening, make sure you like, subscribe, or send this essay to a friend who needs to read it.
— MacKenzie
9 takeaways from the episode
1. The stricter the rule, the faster kids break it.
Think back to your own school days. Did you ever have the experience where a teacher would leave the classroom for five minutes and the room would erupt? The whole class ran on a shared intuition: get away with whatever we can before she comes back.
That’s what happens when rules come from above with no buy-in from the people expected to follow them. The adult becomes the only enforcement mechanism. Which means the moment the adult steps out, the standards go with them.
2. In a traditional classroom, being the troublemaker is the fastest path to status.
There’s a reason the class clown always wins. When rules come from above and kids have no say in shaping them, rebellion becomes the only way to feel powerful. The kids who buck the rules get the laughs, the stories, the social capital. The rule-followers are seen as vanilla. So of course kids goof off and heckle. The system is handing them two options: be obedient and invisible, or disruptive and cool.
One of my favorite things to watch at Alpha is when a new kid shows up and tries the old playbook: the goofing off, the heckling, the performative disengagement. It works for about a day. Then they notice the other kids aren’t laughing. The community has already decided that engagement is the cool thing here. And you can practically see the new kid take off a cloak of performance they’ve been wearing for years. They can finally just be themselves.
3. Kids only live up to standards they helped write.
Plenty of traditional schools claim to have a “culture of excellence,” but the only people enforcing the rules are the teachers. The “cool kids” are the ones breaking them.
At Alpha, the kids enforcing the standards are the ones everyone wants to be like, because the kids wrote the standards themselves. They don’t resent their own rules. They abide by them and defend them.
That’s how you actually create a culture of excellence. You have to let the kids write it.
4. The perfect Town Hall ratio is 95% kids, 5% adults.
Our guide Gaby runs Town Hall for Level 2, our fourth and fifth graders in Austin. When I asked him what makes it work, he laughed and said: “I usually don’t talk in Town Hall.”
The ideal ratio, he told me, is 95% student-led, 5% guide-facilitated. Almost the exact opposite of how a typical classroom runs. And that’s exactly why Town Hall works so well.
5. When kids set their own bar, they set it higher than adults would.
Two years ago, our Level 2 students were voting on the minimum academic workload they’d need to complete each week to qualify for their big end-of-session reward. Our academic team had privately agreed the fair number was around 24 units per week. The kids voted on 16.
The academic team panicked. That was way too low; the kids would never finish their work on time. But our head guide said: Give it time. Let them figure it out for themselves.
By Tuesday of the next week, the kids had called an emergency Town Hall meeting. They’d already realized 16 units wasn’t nearly enough, and some of them were going to finish a full week of academics by Wednesday. So they raised the minimum to 22. By that Friday’s regular Town Hall, they raised it again, this time to 28.
In the end, they set a higher bar for themselves than the adults would have. (And met it.)
All they needed was a little agency and a little room to fail. This is a great lesson for us parents. How can we possibly expect kids to set higher bars for themselves if we never give them the room to do it?
6. Kids enforce the standards they set more strictly than any adult would.
The most common critique I hear about student-led rules is that we’re putting kids in an uncomfortable position: making them tattle on each other, turning peers into enforcers, all of that. Respectfully, that concern almost always comes from adults who’ve never actually watched it happen.
A few weeks ago, a group of Level 2 students got worried that classmates were being unsafe while butt-boarding down a hill at recess. (Butt-boarding, for the uninitiated, is riding those little square scooters from gym class down a hill on your rear end. Very fun. Moderately dangerous.) A handful of them asked to run a mini Town Hall during morning launch. They wanted to set the punishment for violating the safety rules they’d already put in place.
Their proposed punishment was red cards.
Red cards at Alpha are a serious offense: three red cards is a strike, and three strikes means a conversation about whether the school is the right fit. These kids were prepared to hold their own community more accountable than most adults.
7. Kids learn self-governance by failing at it first.
At the beginning of the school year, the Level 2 kids were obsessed with brain rot. (If you don’t have a child between the ages of 8 and 15, brain rot is the umbrella term for gen alpha internet slang — “six seven,” “skibidi toilet,” “tra la la” — chaotic, mostly nonsensical phrases kids shout at each other constantly.) It was driving the guides a little crazy. It was driving the kids crazy too.
So at the first Town Hall of the year, a student proposed a full ban on brain rot. The argument was eloquent. The vote passed. Brain rot was forbidden at Alpha for three full sessions.
Then, at the fourth Town Hall, someone proposed un-banning it. The argument: we’ve grown. We can handle this now. We won’t let it take over.
The vote passed. And here’s the magic: brain rot hasn’t been an issue since. Kids use it during transitions and at recess, not during academics.
They learned self-regulation by being given the authority to legislate it themselves. That’s a life skill your kid is going to need forever. And it’s one traditional schools don’t teach at all.
8. Having high community standards is the #1 way for kids to become the best versions of themselves.
Every Town Hall opens with the same ritual. The Defenders of Democracy call on students around the circle to read the community standards out loud. There are five:
- I am amazing.
- I am the best version of myself.
- I am kind.
- I am respectful.
- I can be trusted.
Because the students helped write these standards, they’re actually motivated to uphold them. (See Takeaway #3.) It’s much more effective for students to say, “In our classroom, we are respectful and kind,” vs. a traditional classroom, where the teacher is top-down enforcing the system: “In my classroom, you will be respectful and kind.”
9. You can run a Town Hall at your dinner table tonight.
Here’s how Gaby suggests implementing Town Hall at home.
Step 1: Define what Town Hall is. Tonight at the dinner table, introduce the idea of Town Hall to your family. Invite your kids to be a part of the space. The whole idea is that you as a family set house rules and own culture. Not saying you need to hand your kid total control over the house, but make sure they know that they have a voice in how things operate. You’re a family, not a dictatorship.
Step 2: Write your community standards. Identify the standards that describe the kind of family you want to be. We tell the truth. We clean up after ourselves. We don’t interrupt. We serve our neighbor. Whatever fits your house. Everyone has to sign off, kids included. These are your community standards and every Town Hall opens by reading them aloud.
Step 3: Assign the roles. Your kids are the Defenders of Democracy. You’re the guide, which means you stay quiet as much as possible. If you have more than one kid, give each of them a specific job: one runs the agenda, one runs the voting, one keeps the log.
Step 4: Set up the agenda box. A jar on the counter works. A note on the fridge works. Anyone in the family can drop in a proposal during the week: a new rule, a complaint, a change they want to see. At Town Hall, the Defenders pull the slips and call on family members to speak, one at a time. (A talking stick helps. A wooden spoon works just as well.)
Step 5: Discuss, vote, and log the outcome. Hear both sides of every proposal. Vote heads-down, eyes-closed. Write down what passed and what didn’t in a running log, and that log will become your family’s living constitution over time.
When we hand kids the authority to create and abide by their own culture, they rarely (if ever) abuse it. They end up asking more from themselves than we do. That’s what happens when you flip the script. And it can start at your dinner table tonight.
Want to hear the full conversation with Gaby? Listen to the episode here.
